If your coffee tastes different after changing the water, you do not need to adjust the grinder immediately. First compare the two waters using one recipe. This is a proposed home comparison, not a report of a completed experiment or a ranking of brands. The aim is to discover which cup you prefer under specific conditions.
Why isolate the water?
Dissolved substances in water can affect coffee flavour, as discussed in a BRITA contribution published by the SCA. In a separate article, researcher Marco Wellinger explains that pH does not substitute for alkalinity information. A “filtered” label therefore does not describe the whole composition. This comparison is not an attempt to determine ideal mineral levels or diagnose water by taste.
Choose two identifiable samples
Use two drinking waters suitable for your equipment according to its instructions. A could be your usual water and B another drinking water you want to try. Record where each comes from and how you prepared it. If you use a filter, note the model and cartridge replacement date. Do not assign unknown mineral values based on a name or price. This plan does not include mixing your own mineral salts.
Keep the rest of the brew constant
Choose a familiar manual brewing recipe, such as Crema’s free V60 recipe. Prepare equal portions of the same coffee from one bag. Keep the grinder setting, coffee dose, water mass, filter, brewer, target temperature and pouring sequence the same. Record the actual brewing time for each sample. Rinse the filter with the water assigned to that sample and empty the receiving vessel before brewing. Rinse the kettle between samples instead of adding B to leftover A. Do not adjust the second recipe to improve its flavour midway through the comparison.
Compare cups at similar temperatures
Label two matching cups A and B. If brewing one after the other, record when each finishes and compare at similar stages of cooling rather than contrasting a very hot cup with a cool one. Try small sips without milk or sugar if you normally drink coffee this way. Describe aroma, perceived acidity, bitterness and aftertaste in your own words. Record preference separately. A simple blank form is: “A: description…, prefer/do not prefer…; B: description…, prefer/do not prefer…”. These are spaces for observations, not predicted results.
Repeat before choosing
On another occasion, reverse the brewing order. You can ask someone to code the samples so that the brand does not suggest an answer. If you spill water, change the grind or one brew takes much longer, note it instead of attributing every difference to the water. Having no clear preference is a valid result; a winner is not compulsory. Limit the conclusion to this coffee, recipe and comparison rather than extending it to every coffee.
Keep a useful record
Write down the date, coffee, water A/B, quantities, grind setting, target temperature, brew times and short descriptions. Do not judge drinking-water safety or machine compatibility from the taste of the coffee. Check the requirements before using your chosen water in a different appliance. If your preference repeats, return to your usual recipe before changing another variable. Crema’s public V60 recipe can provide a consistent reference without promising a particular flavour result.